Categories
Blog #1

Pros and Cons of Digital Text

The concept of creating a highly digital world is something that is very prevalent in society today. Personally, I believe that if these digital archives are created correctly they can be incredibly useful and elevate the efficiency in which people study, but the digital texts that we mainly use in school I find slightly aggravating. In school, from a personal experience, if the material is online it is simply a picture of the text. In this very scenario I will go to the library and print out the reading so I believe that today we still see majority of the resources on paper. I do however see a trend that is shifting with the waves of better technology. As time goes on more and more school will be done completely digitally providing easier access for students.

The advantages that come with creating digital artifacts are obvious. For one, the majority of people on the earth today own a smart device. A smart device is defined as an electrical gadget that will allow an individual to access the internet, surf the web, and connect with others. With the majority of text becoming digital and the overwhelming ownership of smart devices these digital texts become far more convenient for people to access than the actual written text. Furthermore, the more advanced digital archives allow a much easier way to dissect the information making studying easier and easier. If a digital archive is paired with some sort of visual analysis it allows the viewer to gain a broader understanding of the information before diving deeper into the real material. For this very reason I think that most school readings are done and distributed digitally. That being said, all digital readings I am given I will still print out because of personal preference While there are obvious positives, there are also some serious negatives. I personally find it much harder to retain information from a digital source than the physical text. While sifting through an actual book it is much easier take notes in the margins or even underline meaningful information. For those very reasons I still much prefer physical text to a digital version.

There is a lot of room for digital archives to grow and when they are perfected they will provide an efficient way of portraying information that hasn’t been seen before. The aspects of actual text that I find most useful are the abilities to take notes and highlight the important information. I understand that certain sites allow you to highlight the digital text but I still find it less than useful. If the archives kept a record of which pages you highlights it would make it much easier to go back and sift through the work you had done before much easier than archives I have accessed in the past. Another adjustment that I believe needs to be made is the use of margins. Today, we see a spaces underneath the test that allows you to take noted for the entire page, but with the actual text and a margin you can take notes directly next to the section of the reading you find important. With the addition of a visual component that provides a brief summary of the information and the ability to take clear concise notes on the digital texts I could see written texts becoming obsolete.

                                                

Categories
Blog #1

Blog Post #1: “On Material and Digital Archives”

An advantage of creating a digital artifact from archival documents is that there is a much larger amount of data and information available for researchers and the general public. Artifacts and manuscripts that have been too frail for people to look at and use in the past are now accessible. We are now able to use the information, that we never had access to before, to help learn from the past and improve in the future. Researchers and other individuals can link information together and find patterns and trends that they would have never been able to have done before.

This old ship’s log can help us learn from the past, so that we can create a bright future.

However, one of the problems associated with creating digital artifacts is that the computational techniques usually used to store these digital archives cause limitations to those interested in seeing them. Also, the process itself of turning an artifact into a digital archive can be dangerous to the artifact. It is so old and so fragile that it can get damaged very easily. Another problem that I see with creating digital artifacts is the large margin for human error. Most of the times, people are the ones converting the archive to a digital medium and they could misread the writing or accidentally make a typo that makes the artifact inaccurate.

The side by side view of Jane Austen’s Fiction Manuscript in print and the digitized one created by an individual demonstrates the margin for human error and how difficult deciphering manuscripts can be.

I feel that digital archives do not supplant our need to view the physical originals, or enhance the necessity of and desire for archival work. I think that the easy accessibility that digital artifacts provides takes away the excitement for researchers. Though they can just easily look online for the one thing they are looking for instead of having to do research to find it. They will not get to experience the extreme happiness that they feel when they discover something which could eventually cause them to lose passion for their topic of interest. I believe that researchers learn the most when they are looking for information because they run into other data along the way and learn even more when they see the archive in context.

That being said, I feel that open-source and free digitized materials provide opportunities for students and other people looking for specific material to find things that they otherwise would not find. They are able to explore topics in a much deeper manner and discover things that they never even would have thought of. I think the use of these materials also help individuals discover something that interests them that they may have never known existed before looking at digital archives. Students are able to study groups of people that they never heard of and provide them with a much broader perspective on the world and the world’s history.

I believe that because of the creation of digital archives, our research practices have dramatically changed. Most information people need is on the computer and is accessible across the world, so there is no need for individuals to go to the library. Instead of working in groups and dividing up parts of research projects, people are more likely to work on their own and not collaborate with other individuals. I think the use of digital archives have taken the socialization element out of research. I believe that it is a shame because people learn the most from one another and are the most successful when they are working with others because they get different perspectives they would not have thought of otherwise.