Categories
final blog

Final Blog Post

http://grundyhumn100.blogs.bucknell.edu/2018/11/

 

After finishing up transcribing Elizabeth Grundy’s entire memoir, my group and I created a website through WordPress which gave us the freedom to customize the setup of our site. Our group chose to divide the website into six main sections regarding Elizabeth Grundy, as well as all of the work that we put into analyzing her memoir. The first section is the “About” section, where me and the three of my group members all write a short bio about themselves so people are familiar with who we are and where we are from. The second section is titled “Memoir”, and it is a very brief summary of what happens throughout the Elizabeth Grundy memoir. Third we have “Moravian Women”, which offers up some examples of married and non-married Moravian women who struggle between balancing out faith and family. This is actually what inspired our group’s research question, and made us want to find out whether or not there were different relationships between allegiance to family and allegiance to the church in Moravian lives. The next of the six sections is titled “StoryMap”, followed by “Timeline”, and “Visualizations.” For the StoryMap tab my group and I explained the process we used to create our StoryMaps, as well as why they were beneficial to understanding our memoir. The “Timeline” tab is going to be used as a more brief StoryMap, or a short summary of events that occur throughout Grundy’s memoir. Finally, the “Visualizations” is going to be the section where my group and I post screenshots that we have taken of either our website, or anything we have used to help us analyze Elizabeth Grundy’s memoir.

 

This is to give you an idea of what our website looks like, and how we chose to organize our data. The about section is very brief and is just meant to familiarize the audience with everyone in our group. One of the most useful pieces of data we were able to gain access to, is a book that was written by Professor Faull called Moravian Women’s Memoirs. It speaks on the lives of multiple different single as well as married Moravian women, and the difficulty of managing both your family relationships, and your relationship to the church/God. A large majority of these women would completely abandon their families to live their lives as member of a certain church congregation, which tells us that these Moravian churches were very persuasive and had a lot to offer Moravian women.

I was in charge of putting together the “Timeline” section of our website, so I started off by going back to my StoryMap that I created relating events in the memoir to the locations that they occurred. These events and their locations add to the analysis of this memoir by allowing us to see it from a geographical point of view. “Graphic representation is among our most important tools for organizing information”(Grafton 10). Reading a memoir is one thing, but representing themes, ideas and events from the same memoir graphically/geographically, allows us to get a better feel for what was going on in the writing. Combining event and locations, “will allow us to fuse qualitative and quantitative data within real and conceptual space”(Bodenhamer, 12). This is more efficient than it would be to simply analyze the events in the memoir without knowing where about they took place. This way of information visualization takes multiple pieces of this memoir, (that at first we may not even recognize) and combines them together to give us an explanation and gain a deep understanding of what the author was going through. “The virtue of information visualization is that it can make complex data sets more accessible than they otherwise might be”(Whitley, 188). Which is exactly what we have been doing throughout this class all semester long. We have used an endless number of visualization tools that have helped us analyze the text, and combine certain features of the memoir together in order to be able to truly understand what life was life for Elizabeth Grundy. Not just this, but also to understand what life was like to live in this time period for all Moravian women, as well as their friends, husbands and children, and other family members.

The most helpful piece of information in answering our research question is the book that Professor Faull wrote, relating to the relationships Moravian women shared with the church depending on if they were single or married. When simply breaking down and analyzing the text of Elizabeth Grundy’s memoir, creating a timeline that links together most of the major events that happen in the writing, with the places that they occurred. Before taking the time to figure out where all these towns were in relation to one another, I had no way to gauge how far she was traveling at times and how areas surrounding her were structured. Once I gained and understanding I went back to Grundy’s memoir and read it again. This time I was able to look at each individual event that happened in the memoir, and connect that event to a certain place that Grundy mentions in her memoir. I then began trying to memorize where all the churches she went to were located so I could see the smooth flow of her life, rather than trying to piece together all of her actions one by one.

 

When I started this class at the beginning of the semester I had no idea what I was going to be doing with these memoirs outside of transcribing them into modern English which took some time to get used to. It was so unclear to me at first what any of the visualization tools were for and if they were even any help in analyzing the writing. Now we are at the end of the class and it is obvious to me that if it weren’t for all of these tools (Voyant, StoryMapJS, etc), understanding this memoir would have been a much harder struggle, and these tools ultimately took two tasks and turned them into one to save you time.

Categories
Blog #5

Blog #5

Throughout the entire process of creating this timeline for Elizabeth Grundy’s memoir, there have been multiple new perspectives that have been brought to my attention after using StoryMapJS. The whole process was extremely helpful in allowing me to gain a deeper understanding of this memoir, and after creating this timeline I have a much more clear idea of what Elizabeth Grundy’s life was like for her in each of the different places she traveled to throughout her memoir. “We see space as the platform for multiplicity, a realm where all perspectives are particular and dependent upon experiences unique to an individual, a community, or a period of time”(Bodenhamer, 14). Before looking at Grundy’s memoir geo-spatially, reading her memoir could get to be confusing at times where a bunch of different place names are being tossed around. Once I was familiar with all the place names in the memoir, I was able to connect most of the events that happened in this memoir with the location in which they occurred.

After doing this it was like I had gained an entirely new perspective about the memoir that I had never seen before, which is why I selected this quote from Bodenhamer. It shows that space opens up a whole slew of new insight once you start connecting places with other important pieces of the memoir such as people, events, or emotions. “All spaces contain embedded stories on what has happened there. These stories are both individual and collective, and each of them link geography (space) and history (time)”(Bodenhamer, 16). I found the link between space and time to be the most essential piece of bringing the memoir together.

Bodenhamer claims that each individual location that is mentioned in a story has it’s own embedded story behind it, so learning about these locations can help you to understand the writing more closely. In my case with Elizabeth Grundy’s memoir, gaining an understanding of each of the locations in the memoir, and being able to understand which events occurred there made the memoir much seem more smooth and fluent. “[Mapping] promises an alternate view of history and culture through dynamic representation of memory and place, a view that is visual and experiential, fusing qualitative and quantitative data within real and conceptual space”(Bodenhamer, 29). The biggest take away from this whole process for me was learning the different between visual and experiential representations. Mapping with StoryMapJS allows us to incorporate both of these into one efficient representation.

 

https://storymap.knightlab.com/edit/?id=grundy-memoir-caleb

 

Categories
Blog #4

Blog Post #4

Through transcribing Elizabeth Grundy’s memoir I have gained a strong grasp of her life. Distant reading has allowed me to take the 23 pages of her memoir and condense the writing into a short summary. Additionally, creating tags for each individual words had given the memoir a completely different feel when you read through it. These tags help to clarify Grundy’s writing, which helps the reader follow along better and gain a stronger understanding of the memoir. Creating tags was a difficult and tedious process, and some hard decisions had to be made, but they bring so much to the writing that it is worth the process.

For me the process of marking up my transcription has given me a deeper understanding of the text, and has allowed me to get a better feel for what Grundy’s life was like. Adding tags to our group’s transcribed memoir is what Pierazzo calls a diplomatic edition. “A published version of a transcription which reproduces as many of the characteristics of the original document as the medium permits or as the project requires”(Pierazzo, 473). It was tough to choose which words to tag and which ones to leave out. The tags give the transcriptions a lot more detail that makes it easier for the reader, but if you overuse the tags, their purpose will diminish. “An electronic edition is like an iceberg, with far more data potentially available than is actually visible on the screen, and this is at the same time a great opportunity and a temptation to overdo things. When so many possibilities exist, there is a danger of technological considerations of what can be done taking priority over intellectual considerations of what is actually desirable or necessary in any particular case”(Pierazzo, 467). Our group in particular had a problem with deciding whether or not we should tag the words “brother”, “sister”, “son”, and “daughter”. Our transcriptions were already filled with tags and we felt that these words would not be beneficial as we would  be overusing tags. In almost every instance in Grundy’s memoir where one of these words appears, Grundy explains who it is that she is talking about so there is no confusion, which made it easier to decide that we should leave these words untagged. Creating this diplomatic edition has added a lot of nice features to my groups transcriptions, but there are certain features that inevitably cannot be preserved through the process of transcription. “Some characteristics of the manuscript are irredeemably lost by transcribing it, for instance the variable shape and spacing of handwritten glyphs versus the constant shape of digital fonts or typescripts”(Pierazzo, 464). Aside from this, the entire process of creating a diplomatic edition of Elizabeth Grundy’s original memoir has given me a deep look into her life, and I have a strong understanding of what it was like.

Categories
Blog #3 contextual research

Blog #3

The chronology of events is very important if you wish to see the cause and effects of each event, which Grafton emphasizes in this writing.“By comparing individual histories to one another and the uniform progress of the years, the reader could see the hand of providence at work” (Grafton, 15). Through chronology, we are able to view changes that have happened over the years, and why it is that they changed. There are an endless number of ways to create timelines, and each of them reveals different information about a sequence of events, and they can incorporate images and other media.

Along with chronology, timelines show geography which tells viewers where the event happened, along what time it happened. “Timelines are relatively new sources of information, only formed as they are today in the middle of the 18th century”(Grafton, 19). Timelines are relatively new, so different ideas and methods of making timelines are always being created. In this case, creating a timeline of events to view Elizabeth Grundy’s life helps to view her life as a whole, and gain a better and more full understanding of what it was like to be her. Grafton would agree that graphic visualization is one of the most helpful tools, if not the most helpful when it comes to organizing information into a concise set of data. “Graphic representation is among our most important tools for organizing information” (Grafton, 10).

Here is a specific event from the life of Elizabeth Grundy that my group and I incorporated into our timeline. This was when Grundy was in her 50’s, five years after she had moved to Dukinfield. She started up a girls school, with eleven girls all belonging to families of the Brethren church.

This photo shows a few of the most common illnesses in the 1700’s. We chose this because in her memoir, Grundy talks about the death of multiple family members which led us to believe there was a problem with sickness at this time.